AIS Canberra Darters

Between 2004 and 2006, McMeniman played for AIS Canberra Darters in the Commonwealth Bank Trophy league. Her Darters team mates included Laura Geitz.^{[5][8][9][10][11][12]} In 2005 she received the league's Best New Talent award.^[13]

Queensland Firebirds

Between 2007 and 2016, McMeniman played for Queensland Firebirds, originally in the Commonwealth Bank Trophy league and subsequently in the ANZ Championship. After helping Firebirds win the 2011 ANZ Championship, she initially announced her retirement. However, after missing the 2012 and 2013 seasons, she returned to play for Firebirds in 2014. She subsequently helped Firebirds win two further ANZ Championships in 2015 and 2016. Together with Romelda Aiken and Laura Geitz, McMeniman was one of only three players who featured in all three Championship winning squads.^{[14][15][16][17][18][19][20]}

Australia

McMeniman was a member of the Australia U21 that won a bronze medal at the 2005 World Youth Netball Championships^{[1][12][13][15]} On 22 October 2014, McMeniman made her senior Australia debut during a Test series against England.^[19][21][22] Together with Erin Bell, she subsequently co-captained Australia at the 2014 Fast5 Netball World Series.^[22][23] McMeniman was included in an 18-player squad for the 2015 Netball World Cup but missed out on selection when the squad was reduced to 12.^{[4][24][25][26]}

In January 2016 McMeniman captained Australia when they won an away Test series against England.^[27][28] She subsequently captained Australia as they won the 2016 Netball Quad Series.^{[25][26][29][30]} She retired as a netball player after leading Australia to victory in the 2016 Constellation Cup.^{[6][30][31][32][33]}

Tournaments	Place
2005 World Youth Netball Championships[1][12][13][15]
2014 Fast5 Netball World Series[22][23][34]
2016 Netball Quad Series[26][25][29][30]
2016 Constellation Cup.[6][30][31][32][33]