Comparison between Natural Circulation and Forced Circulation

A forced circulation boiler is a boiler where a pump is used to circulate water inside the boiler. This differs from a natural circulation boiler which relies on current density to circulate water inside the boiler. In some forced circulation boilers, the water is circulated at twenty times the rate of evaporation.[1]

In water tube boilers, the way the water is recirculated inside the boiler before becoming steam can be described as either natural circulation or forced circulation. In a water tube boiler, the water is recirculated inside until the vapor pressure of the water overcomes the vapor pressure inside the stream drum and becomes saturated steam. The forced circulation boiler begins the same as a natural circulation boiler, at the feed water pump. Water is introduced into the steam drum and is circulated around the boiler, leaving only as steam. What makes the forced circulation boiler different is its use of a secondary pump that circulates water through the boiler. The secondary pump takes the feed water going to the boiler and raises the pressure of the water going in. In a natural circulation boilers, the circulation of water is dependent on the differential pressures caused by the change of density in the water as it is heated. That is to say that as the water is heated and starts turning to steam, the density decreases sending the hottest water and steam to the top of the furnace tubes.

In contrast to the natural circulation boiler, the forced circulation boiler uses a water circulation pump to force that flow instead of waiting for the differential to form. Because of this, the generation tubes of a forced circulation boiler are able to be oriented in whatever way is required by space constraints. Water is taken from the drum and forced through the steel tubes.[2] In this way it is able to produce steam much faster than that of a natural circulation boiler.

Types

LaMont

One example of a forced circulation boiler is the LaMont boiler. Such boilers are used in cases where there is high pressure, above 30 megapascals.[3]

Clayton

The Clayton forced-circulation steam generator does not have a steam drum in the typical sense. A series of small tubes that are part of one giant coil, usually made of steel, have feed water pumped through at great speed. The water is pumped from the top of the steam generator down to the bottom and out. The tubes that are arranged in such a way that the combustion gasses pass around the tube subsequently heating the water. Essentially, the arrangement can be best described as having a large thin walled coil of pipe wrapping around the circumference of a vertical steel drum looping around and down until it reaches the bottom. As only some of the water may become steam, it is important to separate the two and send any water back through to absorb more heat. If this separation does not occur, the damage to the system could be costly. If steam goes through the generation tubes inside, the tubes may overheat and become weak, and if water is allowed down into the steam system, corrosion, water hammer, or other ill effects may occur. To combat this, after exiting the steam generator, the mixture is put through a centrifugal steam separator which does exactly that producing steam that is above ninety-nine percent dry saturated steam.[4] If superheated steam is desired, an additional coil is run back through the steam generator. To maintain a constant level of water in the steam separator, the feed pump in conjunction with a leveling system is utilized. A great advantage to this system is that steam can be generated very quickly. However, the downside to this system is the complete dependence on a constant supply of feed water. Without the constant supply, the system may be subject to a massive and expensive damage [5]

Advantages

  • The evaporator tubes may be built in any orientation. Natural circulation requires vertical piping whereas the forced circulation ensures flow in any direction.[6]
  • The walls of the tube may be built smaller due to the greater tolerance of higher pressure losses.[6]
  • The general forced circulation boiler has a low circulation ratio of range between three and ten. The circulation ratio is how much steam is produced per how much feed was put in. Natural circulation boilers have a huge range of circulation ratios all the way from five to one hundred.[6]

Disadvantages

  • The forced circulation boiler requires more power and water than a natural circulation boiler. This is due to the electrical requirements of the pump forcing circulation and the amount of water being circulated through the tubes.[6]
  • The additional parts required; steam drum, circulation pump, and orifices to limit flow, cause a forced circulation boiler to lead to increased cost as well as increased opportunities for failure which gives them a lower reliability than natural circulation.[6]
  • The pump must be beneath the steam drum to take advantage of the pressure due to the height of the water. If the pump was not there; when it reaches the steam separator and water returns to the pump, the pressure may become low enough in the eye of the impeller to cause cavitation and subsequent damage.[6]
  • Since there are two pumps, controlling them and having them work in sync and cooperation proves difficult.
  • The boiler is not able to produce super-critical pressures because the steam generation is not dependent on pressure differences[6]

See also

References

  1. ↑ Boilers Operators Handbook Second Edition Graham and Totman pg 58 ISBN 1 85333 285 2
  2. ↑ Ganapathy, Viswanathan (October 2013). "UNDERSTANDING BOILER CIRCULATION" (PDF). www.che.com. Chemical Engineering. Retrieved 2 April 2016.
  3. ↑ Springer Handbook of Mechanical Engineering 10 Volume Karl-Heinrich Grote, Erik K. Antonsson part C 16.24 ISBN 978-3-540-49131-6
  4. ↑ "CLAYTON STEAM SYSTEMS IN THE POWER INDUSTRY" (PDF). Clayton Industries. Clayton Industries. 2008. Retrieved 2 April 2016.
  5. ↑ Hunt, Everett C. (1999). Modern Marine Engineer's Manual, Vol. 1. Cornell Maritime Pr. ISBN 978-0870334962.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Sebastian, Tier (2002). Steam/Water Circulation Design (PDF). Energy Engineering and Environmental Protection Publications.
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.