2011–2012: Foundation

The formation of the USA Rugby League was announced on January 12, 2011. Seven teams that had previously competed in the American National Rugby League, the United States' established rugby league organization and recognized governing body for the sport, announced they were breaking with the AMNRL to form a new league. The stated reason for the split was dissatisfaction with the governance of the AMNRL; the departing teams were unhappy with the lack of club involvement in the league's decision making, and the new league was founded with the principle of including its member clubs in its administration.^[2][3][4]

The departing AMNRL teams were the Boston Thirteens, the Washington, D.C. Slayers, the Fairfax Eagles, the Jacksonville Axemen, the New Haven Warriors, the Philadelphia Fight, and the Pittsburgh Vipers; they were to be joined by two new teams, the New Jersey Turnpike Titans and Kodiak Rugby from New York City. Before the season Pittsburgh and Fairfax became "developmental" teams in the new league outside of the top-tiered competition; Fairfax subsequently suspended operations.^[5] The New York team was unable to find a suitable stadium in the city, and instead became the Rhode Island Rebellion.^[6] One additional team, Oneida FC, joined the top-tiered competition for the 2011 season.^[7]

On January 13, 2011, the USARL announced that Peter Illfield, chairman of the Philadelphia Fight, would be the league's first chairman.^[8][9] The league's first event was a rugby league nines tournament in the Philadelphia area on May 28–29, 2011. Round 1 of the regular season championship kicked off on June 4; the Jacksonville Axemen won the minor premiership with the best regular season record. In the inaugural Grand Final on August 27, the Philadelphia Fight defeated the New Haven Warriors to win their first ever national championship.^[10]

2013–2014: Expansion

In 2013 the USARL and AMNRL increased their focus on reunification, particularly after the United States' encouraging showing at the 2013 Rugby League World Cup. An independent commission assembled to lead negotiations, however the USARL clubs eventually pulled out. USARL commissioner Peter Illfield blamed apparent dysfunction and disorganization in the AMNRL organization for this decision. The USARL subsequently invited AMNRL clubs to join their ranks as full members and initiated a four-team expansion.^[11]

In 2014, the USARL expanded to 10 teams, adding expansion squads Atlanta Rhinos, Central Florida Warriors, and Tampa Mayhem. In addition, the Northern Virginia Eagles withdrew from the AMNRL and joined the USARL.^[12] To reduce operating costs, the competition was split into two conferences.^[13] Meanwhile, the AMNRL suspended its 2014 season.

2015–2020: AMNRL folds

In 2015, the AMNRL folded, leaving the USARL as the undisputed top-level rugby league competition in the United States. Three former AMNRL clubs joined the USARL; Bucks County Sharks, Connecticut Wildcats, and New York Knights. The Delaware Black Foxes also joined as an expansion squad. For 2016, the Connecticut Wildcats left the competition and were replaced by the White Plains Wombats. Before the 2017 season, the D.C. Slayers and Bucks County Sharks left the competition, and the USARL abolished the division structure within the North Conference. Before the 2018 season, the Central Florida Warriors left the competition and were replaced by Southwest Florida Copperheads and Danny Hanson was appointed the second league chairman. The Rhode Island Rebellion also left the competition. The New York Knights left the competition after the 2018 season.^[14]

2021–2022: NARL era

USARL membership has been in flux since the announcement of the North American Rugby League in spring 2021. Boston 13s and Philadelphia Fight left USARL to be founding members of the new competition. White Plains folded after NARL established the New York Freedom. Northern Virginia folded after most of its players joined the newly established DC Cavalry in NARL. Lakeland Renegades suspended operations due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

The 2021 USARL season was contested by six teams. Philadelphia and Delaware in the North; Tampa, Jacksonville, Southwest Florida Copperheads, and South Florida Speed in the South. USARL South Championships Tampa Mayhem defeated North winners Delaware Black Foxes in the championship. The North Division has been unable to play in 2022. Multiple forfeits by South Florida Speed in July 2022 have put their future with USARL in doubt.

2023: Playing on both Coasts

2023 has seen significant expansion. Atlanta Rhinos rejoined the USARL, playing in the South Division. Pacific Coast Rugby League (PCRL) joined USARL, operating on the West Coast. PCRL brought Los Angeles Mongrel, San Diego Barracudas, and Santa Rosa Dead Pelicans – all formerly part of California Rugby League – as well as the newly formerly Los Angeles Bandidos into USARL. Additionally, four Utah teams, Riverton Seagulls, Herriman Roosters, Glendale Storm and Provo Broncos began playing USARL sanctioned matches as affiliates of PCRL. In August 2023, the first ever coast to coast National Champion was crowned with Santa Rosa Dead Pelicans defeating defending champions Jacksonville Axemen, 20–16.

Regular season

The USARL is split into two conferences, South and Pacific Coast. In the South Conference, teams play a double round-robin schedule of 8 games. In the Pacific, the ran by the Pacific Coast Rugby League is split into two Conferences, known by their respective state in Utah and California. Both conferences play a double round-robin schedule of 6 games. Teams qualify for the playoffs based on point differential, with a win counting for 2 points, a draw for 1, a loss for 0, and a forfeit for −2. The regular season runs through May and July.

Play-offs

In the South Conference, the top four teams make the playoffs. The teams with the best and worst records, and the second- and third-best records, play each other in the South Conference semi-finals. The winners meet in the South Conference finals. In the Pacific Coast Conference, the top two teams in the each state will play-off to be their respective conference champion. Afterwards, the Utah and California champions meet to crown the overall champion. The winners of the South Conference finals meet the winners of the Pacific Coast Conference finals in the USARL Grand Final, held in late August or early September.

Former teams

Former Teams
Colors	Club	Years Active	City (MSA)	Stadium	Titles (Last)
	Baltimore Blues	2012–2014	Baltimore		0 (N/A)
	Boston Thirteens	2011–2020	Boston	Eastern Boston Stadium	1 (2015)
	Brooklyn Kings	2014–2020	Brooklyn	Randalls Island Field 10	1 (2019)
	Bucks County Sharks	1997–2016	Bucks County, PA (Trenton)	Falls Township Park	0 (N/A)
	Central Florida Warriors	2014–2017	Deland, FL	Spec Martin Stadium	0 (N/A)
	Connecticut Wildcats	2003–2015	Norwalk, CT	Andrews Field	0 (N/A)
	D.C. Slayers	2003–2016	Washington, D.C.	Duke Ellington Field	0 (N/A)
	Delaware Black Foxes	2015–2020	Wilmington, DE	Eden Park Stadium	0 (N/A)
	Northern Virginia Eagles	2007–2020	Nokesville, VA	Grizzly Sports Complex	0 (N/A)
	Lakeland Renegades	2019–2020	Lakeland, FL	All Saints Academy	0 (N/A)
	New Haven Warriors	2006–2012	West Haven, CT (New Haven)	Ken Strong Stadium	0 (N/A)
	New Jersey Turnpike Titans	2011–2012	Jersey City, NJ	Cochran Stadium	0 (N/A)
	New York Knights	1997–2018*	New York City	The Castle Pier 40	0 (N/A)
	Oneida FC	2011–2012	Cambridge, MA	Henry G. Steinbrenner Stadium	0 (N/A)
	Philadelphia Fight	1998–2020	Conshohocken, PA (Philadelphia)	Garthwaite Stadium	4 (2016)
	Rhode Island Rebellion	2011–2017	Providence, RI	Marvel Field	0 (N/A)
	South Florida Speed	2021	Miami, FL	North Dade Optimist Park	0 (N/A)
	White Plains Wombats	2016–2020	White Plains, NY	Blind Brook Elementary School	0 (N/A)

Winners

Winners	Count	Years
Philadelphia Fight	4	2011, 2013, 2014, 2016
Jacksonville Axemen	3	2012, 2018, 2022
Brooklyn Kings	1	2019
Boston 13s	1	2015
Atlanta Rhinos	1	2017
Tampa Mayhem	1	2021
Santa Rosa Dead Pelicans	1	2023

Representative sides

New England Immortals

The New England Immortals RLFC were founded in 2010 and consisted of the top players from the 3 New England based AMNRL clubs. They played their inaugural match against the Canadian National Team, on July 31, 2010, defeating the Canadians 12–8 in a tightly contested match. After the AMNRL/USARL split in 2011, the Immortals were transferred to the USARL and became the only form of representation for USARL clubs due to the RLIF regulation that USARL-based players could not represent the Tomahawks. The Immortals took to the field for their second match since their inception, and despite putting up a hard fight, they were out classed by the more experienced Marines, losing by a score of 68–12. As of 2014, due to budgetary cuts and restructuring of the USARL competition, the Immortals have not played a match since their loss to the Royal Marines.

USA Pioneers

In 2014, the league established a touring developmental side, the USA Pioneers, to play friendly matches against foreign nations. They completed a two match tour in Jamaica in April 2014, winning their first game against a Jamaican domestic outfit, but fell short to the semi-professional Hurricanes Rugby League whilst still proving to be strong opposition for the Jamaicans.^[16] The Pioneers played a friendly against a touring New Zealand Police squad the following August, losing 6–62 against very strong opposition.

Presidents Barbarians

The USARL established another team to play a second match against the New Zealand Police and to 'curtain-raise' the 2014 USARL National Championship between the Philadelphia Fight and the Jacksonville Axemen. This representative consisted of overseas-imports from Australia, New Zealand, United Kingdom and France; similar to Super League's Exiles. They were beaten by the Kiwis 16–46.

USARL Representative teams
Club	Representation	Established	Match history
New England Immortals	New England	2010	W 12–8 Canada July 31, 2010 L 12–68 Royal Marines April 27, 2012
USARL Pioneers	Development (non-internationals)	2013	W 46–26 Duhaney Park Red Sharks April 3, 2013 L 30–50 Hurricanes Rugby League April 7, 2013 L 6–62 New Zealand Blue Thunder August 16, 2013
Presidents Barbarians	'Exiles' (overseas imports)	2013	L 16–46 New Zealand Blue Thunder August 23, 2013
NORTH Conference All-Stars	North of America	2015	L 20–34 SOUTH Conference All-Stars August 29, 2015 L 32–38 SOUTH Conference All-Stars October 22, 2016
SOUTH Conference All-Stars	South of America	2015	W 34–20 NORTH Conference All-Stars August 29, 2015 W 38–32 NORTH Conference All-Stars October 22, 2016