Background

Judgment Day was first held as the 25th In Your House pay-per-view (PPV) in October 1998; In Your House was a series of monthly PPV shows first produced by the World Wrestling Federation (WWF, now WWE) in May 1995. The "In Your House" branding was officially retired following April 1999's event Backlash: In Your House, as the company moved to install permanent names for each of its monthly PPVs.^[3] Over the Edge, which was also previously an "In Your House" branded event, was held as its own PPV in May 1999, but due to the tragic death of wrestler Owen Hart, the WWF would cancel that PPV chronology and reinstated Judgment Day as its own PPV to be held on May 21, 2000, at Freedom Hall in Louisville, Kentucky. This second Judgment Day event established it as the promotion's annual May PPV.^[4]

Storylines

The main event of the evening was a 60-minute Iron Man match between Triple H and the then-current WWF Champion, The Rock. At WrestleMania 2000, Vince McMahon turned on The Rock and helped Triple H retain his title, joining his daughter Stephanie and son Shane in the McMahon-Helmsley Regime with Triple H and D-Generation X. In the weeks leading up to Backlash, The Rock and Triple H's hostility had seemingly reached its climax. With the help of Stone Cold Steve Austin, The Rock defeated Triple H at Backlash to win the WWF Championship. The next week on Raw, Triple H stated that his rivalry with The Rock was "just beginning", and the following week, challenged Rock to a 60-minute Iron Man match for the WWF Title, One week later, Shawn Michaels would make a surprise return to the company, announcing that he would serve as special guest referee for the match.

Another major rivalry heading into the event saw Shane McMahon begin a rivalry with the Big Show. Leading into WrestleMania, Shane had aligned himself with Big Show, who at the time was feuding with The Rock after Rock's victory in January's Royal Rumble match. Shane would then interfere in their match at No Way Out in February and help Big Show win, which earned Show the #1 contendership and a match with then-WWF Champion Triple H, whom Big Show had previously defeated for the title at Survivor Series in November 1999. The match eventually grew to include The Rock and Mick Foley, and Big Show was the first wrestler eliminated from the ensuing Elimination Fatal-Four-Way main event. After WrestleMania, with Shane primarily siding with Triple H, Big Show began a brief period where he would imitate other wrestlers in a comedic role, which would lead him to gradually become a fan favorite. This earned him ridicule from Shane, so the two began a rivalry that led to a match at Judgment Day.

Another feud involving the Regime was DX's feud with the Dudley Boyz, which had started when the Dudleyz defeated the New Age Outlaws at No Way Out for the WWF Tag Team Championship and caused the breakup of the Outlaws. Although the Dudleys did help out the Regime at times, they eventually turned on them and became heroes in the eyes of the fans. At the time, Bubba Ray Dudley had taken to powerbombing many of the WWF's female wrestlers through tables and was keen on doing so to Tori, who was X-Pac's storyline girlfriend. This led to a Tag Team Tables match being set for Judgment Day.

The ongoing rivalry between Chris Benoit and Chris Jericho over the WWF Intercontinental Championship began at WresleMania 2000 where Benoit and Jericho, along with Kurt Angle, faced each other in a Two-Fall Triple Threat match for both Angle's Intercontinental Championship and European Championship. Benoit won the Intercontinental Championship after pinning Jericho, while Jericho won the European Championship after pinning Benoit. Jericho lost the European Championship to Eddie Guerrero the following night on Raw after Chyna turned on Jericho and aligned with Guerrero. Benoit would defend the Intercontinental Championship against Jericho at Backlash where Benoit won by disqualification after Jericho used the title belt to defend himself from Benoit's Diving Headbutt and was disqualified as a result. Benoit and Jericho had a rematch for the title on the May 4 episode of SmackDown! which Jericho won after hitting Benoit with the title belt and hitting him with the Lionsault. After aiding The Rock, confronting and insulting the McMahon-Helmsley Regime, Jericho was forced to defend the Intercontinental Championship on the May 8 episode of Raw. After retaining the title against Kurt Angle and later Big Show, Jericho lost the Intercontinental Championship back to Benoit after special guest referee Triple H purposely got distracted by his wife Stephanie McMahon-Helmsley while Benoit tapped out to the Walls of Jericho and, after Jericho hit him to get his attention, Triple H hit Jericho from behind causing Jericho to be locked in Benoit's Crippler Crossface before Triple H called for the bell and awarded the title to Benoit despite Jericho not submitting. Benoit later announced that he would give Jericho a rematch for the Intercontinental Championship at Judgment Day in a submission match.

Preliminary matches

The event opened with Team ECK (Kurt Angle, Edge, and Christian) facing Too Cool (Scotty 2 Hotty, Grand Master Sexay, and Rikishi). Grand Master Sexay performed the Hip Hop Drop on Edge to win the match.

Next, Eddie Guerrero defended the WWF European Championship against Perry Saturn and Dean Malenko in a Triple Threat match. After Chyna hit Saturn with a lead pipe that was hidden in a bouquet of roses, Guererro pinned Malenko with an Oklahoma Roll to retain the title.

After that, Shane McMahon faced Big Show in a Falls Count Anywhere match. After interference from Big Boss Man, Test, Albert, Trish Stratus and Bull Buchanan, Shane pushed an amplifier onto Big Show's leg and hit him with a cinderblock to win the match.

Later, Chris Benoit defended the WWF Intercontinental Championship against Chris Jericho in a Submission match. Jericho passed out to the Crippler Crossface by Benoit, meaning Benoit won the match and retained the title.

In the fifth match, D-Generation X (Road Dogg and X-Pac) faced The Dudley Boyz (Bubba Ray Dudley and D-Von Dudley) in a Tag Team Tables match. X-Pac performed a Super X-Factor through a table on Bubba to win the match.

Main event

In the main event, The Rock defended the WWF Championship against Triple H in a 60-minute Iron Man match with Shawn Michaels as the special guest referee. Rock performed a Rock bottom on Triple H to make the score 1–0. Triple H performed a Pedigree on Rock to make the score 1–1. Triple H pinned Rock with a Small Package to make the score 2–1. Triple H performed a Piledriver on Rock to make the score 3–1. Rock performed a DDT on Triple H to make the score 3–2. Triple H was disqualified for attacking Rock with a steel chair, making the score 3–3. Triple H immediately pinned Rock using the ropes for leverage to make the score 4–3. Rock passed out to a Sleeper Hold by Triple H, causing a TKO and making the score 5–3. Triple H was counted out after Rock performed a Pedigree on an announce table to Triple H, making the score 5–4. Rock performed a People's Elbow on Triple H to make the score 5–5. After Road Dogg and X-Pac interfered, The Undertaker would make his return from injury, debuting his "American Badass" gimmick, and attacked Road Dogg, X-Pac, Shane McMahon and Vince McMahon. Undertaker attacked Triple H with a Chokeslam and a Tombstone Piledriver as the time limit expired. Rock was disqualified for Undertaker's interference, meaning Triple H won the match 6–5 and the title.

Iron man match