Bishop of Killaloe

Following the death of Thomas McRedmond on 5 April 1904, Fogarty was appointed Bishop of Killaloe by Pope Pius X on 8 July. He was consecrated by the Archbishop of Cashel-Emly, Thomas Fennelly, on 4 September in the Pro-Cathedral of Saints Peter and Paul, Ennis.

During his episcopate, Fogarty involved himself closely in the social and political challenges facing Ireland, frequently speaking out against landlordism and supporting tenant ownership and agricultural self-sufficiency.^[3] He also intervened in labour disputes in the early part of his episcopate, intervening in the West Clare Railway strike in 1910.

Fogarty was also known for his oratory skills, and was chosen to give the graveside oration at the burial of the Bishop of Limerick, Edward O'Dwyer, in May 1917.

While it was said that he disapproved of the Easter Rising, Fogarty signed the 1917 manifesto against the partition of Ireland, and later protested against the "hideous atrocities" perpetrated by the triumph of British culture on Irish nationalists.^[4] He also shared a platform with Éamon de Valera in the 1917 East Clare by-election campaign, and in the lead-up to the 1918 general election decried the threat of conscription being introduced to Ireland, insisting that the Irish were "not slaves" of the British Empire. Fogarty developed a close relationship with the first President of the Executive Council, W. T. Cosgrave.^[3]

In 1919, Fogarty purchased Westbourne House on the western outskirts of Ennis, for use as a residence for him and his successors.^[3][1]

As well as acting as a trustee for the first Dáil loan in December 1920, he held talks on peace proposals in Dublin with the Archbishop of Perth and Clare native, Patrick Clune, during what was regarded as an assassination attempt by Black and Tans who attacked his Westbourne residence in Ennis. On the evening of 2 December, Fogarty received a telegram from the Archbishop of Melbourne, Daniel Mannix, asking him to meet Clune in All Hallows College on 4 December, to which he reluctantly agreed. He set off on 3 December, staying the night in St John's Hospital, Limerick, while four auxiliaries of the Black and Tans raided Westbourne with the intent "to take [his] body, carry [him] off, and, according to General Crozier, bury [his] body in the Shannon".^[3][5][6]

Fogarty's Lenten pastoral letter in 1921 stayed true to the republican position, insisting that Irish nationalists only had to "remain steadfast to win" a united Ireland, and that "anyone who knows the psychology of the Irish people is well aware that brute force will never appease them nor intimidate them into surrender of their national rights".^[1]

While he was a vocal supporter of republicans during the War of Independence, Fogarty surprised many by supporting the Anglo-Irish Treaty, insisting that rejecting it would be "an act of national madness", and later insisting in his Lenten pastoral letter in 1922 that the problem of partition would be solved in time.^[1] Writing to the rector of the Irish College in Rome, Patrick Hagan, he criticised anti-Treaty propaganda, suggesting that voters should "pay no attention to all the talk about surrendering their birthright", for "they know their own minds".^[7]

Although his interest in politics receded after independence, Fogarty is believed to have found it difficult to forgive de Valera for his actions during the Civil War, criticising the Anglo-Irish trade war that followed Fianna Fáil's victory in the 1932 general election as "tariff madness".^[1]

Fogarty unveiled a memorial to Arthur Griffith, Michael Collins and Kevin O'Higgins in Dublin in 1951, paying generous tribute to their role in the foundation of the Irish state. He was also known to be a passionate horseman, cattle breeder and agriculturist, winning prizes at agricultural shows throughout the country for his horticultural produce.^[1]

Archbishop of Killaloe

On 8 July 1954, in recognition of his long and distinguished episcopate, Fogarty was honoured with the "privileges and honours of bishops assisting at the pontifical throne" and conferred with the title of archbishop ad personam by Pope Pius XII.^[1]

Fogarty celebrated the golden jubilee of his episcopate on 29 August 1954, itself an almost unique event in the history of the church. It was considered to be the most magnificent religious spectacle ever seen in Ennis, with guests including the Primate of All Ireland, John d'Alton, and President Seán T. O'Kelly among those who participated in festivities marking the occasion. The people of Ennis honoured the occasion by erecting a statue of the Virgin Mary in the grounds of the Pro-Cathedral.^[1]

He had the longest episcopate in the recent history of the Catholic hierarchy in Ireland, and it was only towards the end of his life that he availed of the assistance of a coadjutor bishop, to which Joseph Rodgers was appointed on 10 January 1948. Rodgers lived at Ashline House on the Kilrush Road in Ennis, which had been made available for him by Fogarty by means of an eviction.^[8]