Naming, mascot, and school colors selection

In early April 2016, the Lafayette School Board made their final decision on the name for Southside High School, after the naming process had begun in December 2015. In a 8–1 vote, the current name was voted for by members of the board. Some of the other proposed names were Youngsville High School, Caneview High, Cypress High, and Steven Bennett High School. The selection of the school's name was highly debated by the board.^[9] Youngsville Mayor Ken Ritter stated that he felt that naming the school Youngsville High School would "invoke a sense of place and a sense of pride".^[10] The motion to name the school after Bennett, a late U.S. Air Force Captain, was voted against in a 8–1 vote.

After the name of the high school was decided, principal Catherine Cassidy formed a student committee on which students from the surrounding zoned schools served on. The goal was to decide what mascot the school would adopt as well as the colors of the school. The shark was "overwhelmingly voted" to be the school's mascot, (although the committee had also considered the yellow jacket or a hornet), and the school’s colors were chosen to be teal, navy, and silver. ^[11]

Construction and opening

Later in April 2016, construction for the high school began. It was designed by Abell Crozier Davis Architects and Pfluger Architects, with construction managed by The Lemoine Company. Lafayette Parish Superintendent Donald Aguillard vowed that the school would have a focus on the arts, as well as being a technology-rich environment. The project cost the district more than $60 million.^[12]

According to Aguillard, the decision to construct the school in Youngsville marked the first time in 47 years that a new public high school was built in Lafayette Parish:

The decision to build here in Youngsville is one of courage, especially since there are so many needs in the school system across the parish. We’re breaking ground today for the first new public high school built in Lafayette Parish in 47 years. That’s … wow. As we move public education in Lafayette Parish into the 21st century, we are going to work diligently to ensure that all of our education needs are fulfilled.

In late 2016, the logo for the high school was chosen.^[13] On August 9, 2017, the school opened, welcoming about 675 freshmen and sophomore students.^[14]

Spike in enrollment

In December 2018, the district announced plans to address an unexpected increase in enrollment figures. At the time, the school had 1,568 enrolled students across three grade levels, an increase of 548 students from 2017. Several solutions were proposed, including moving six portable classroom buildings to the high school, a small-scale rezoning to move some students to another school, and collapsing several of the school's collaborative spaces into traditional classrooms.^[15]

District Chief Administrative Officer Joe Craig suggested several reasons for the rise in enrollment, including the residential construction happening in the area, and the Acadiana Renaissance Charter Academy only enrolling students up to eighth grade.

In late 2019, the school's enrollment numbers sat at 1,683 students, 283 students over what the school's classrooms were designed to accommodate. Originally, six portable buildings were going to be moved to the school to resolve this enrollment spike, but this would've cost $260,000 in school system funds to pay for the needed infrastructure, causing the board to reject the plan in October 2019.

The board responded to concerns about possible rezoning, and the decline in enrollment to Comeaux High School from 2016 to 2019 in September 2019, stating that this was intentional: the school was opened to alleviate overcrowding and temporary classrooms like those found at Comeaux High School.^[16] In December 2019, the Lafayette Parish School Board approved two new portable buildings in a 5–3 vote.^[17]

Temporary closure in November 2020

In November 2020, the school temporarily closed for two weeks to prevent the spread of COVID-19. From November 15 to November 30, the school would shift to virtual learning only. The move came after an evaluation showed that 11% of the school's students had contacted the virus from community activities outside the school. A few other schools either temporarily closed or cancelled activities at around the same time, including the temporary closure of Loreauville High School from November 11, 2020, to November 20, 2020.^[18]

Police investigation into alleged abuse of special education students

On March 31, 2021, the Youngsville Police Department began investigating abuse allegations against a teacher who was reported to have grabbed, poked, and slapped Special Education students.^[19] Laurie Gresham (a former substitute teacher at the school) had released a voluntary statement about the alleged abuse on the same day, and was fired after discussing it with Board members. Two victims were identified as alleged victims of the teacher in question. The mother of one of the alleged victims withdrew her son from the school, and considered legal action against the administration, after Southside administrators had told her to write a statement in support of the teacher and lied to her about there being only one incident, as well as the existence of surveillance footage.

In the incident allegedly captured on video, the teacher "grabbed the student by the neck and yelled at him". The incident shown in the video occurred on March 10, 2019, and Kathy Aloisio, who is the middle and secondary schools director,^[20] said that she had learned of the incident on March 19. In a recorded meeting with Gresham, Aloisio was "mortified when [she] saw it".

State law and district policy only authorizes physical restraints as a last resort for SPED student behavior that presents "imminent risk of harm to themselves or others". In addition, said physical restraint must be "directly proportionate to the circumstances and to the student’s size, age, and severity of behavior".^[21] The use of physical restraint is required to be notified to parents in writing within 24 hours: in the mother's case, she was notified with a brief phone call on March 22.

The mother stated that, while she does not know if the use of physical restraint was done in an intentionally harmful manner or not (she had not seen the video), she was more "appalled by the fact that other incidents are happening in the classroom that [were] not reported to me.”

Lafayette Parish School System Public Information Officer Allison Dickerson said the system "could not provide comment [about the incident] as these are personnel matters."^[22]

Mercury spill incident

On April 17, 2023, a student brought a vial of mercury to the school, which was then dropped and spilled onto the floor of an undisclosed classroom. Waste cleanup agencies, as well as the Department of Environmental Quality, were called, and crisis response protocols were engaged.^[23] The spill was properly contained and did not affect the air quality of the school. It is not known why the student brought the mercury to school.^[24] The school was closed until April 19th, 2023 in order for the spill to be properly contained.