Zin Mar Nwe
Born
Zin Mar Nwe

2001 (age 22–23)[1]
Myanmar
NationalityBurmese
OccupationDomestic maid (former)
Criminal statusImprisoned at Changi Women's Prison
MotiveOut of anger over alleged mistreatment by the victim
Conviction(s)Murder under Section 300(c) of the Penal Code (one count)
Criminal charge1st charge: Murder of a 70-year-old woman by stabbing
PenaltyLife imprisonment[2]

On 25 June 2018, at Singapore's Choa Chu Kang, 17-year-old Zin Mar Nwe, a foreign maid from Myanmar, used a knife to stab her employer's mother-in-law, who was alleged to have abused the maid. The 70-year-old elderly victim, an Indian national, sustained 26 knife wounds and died from acute haemorrhage caused by the stabbing. Zin was arrested not long after the killing and charged with murder. Although the victim was initially named in the local and international media, her name was subsequently not reported to protect the identity of one of her family members who was underage.

Zin, who claimed that she was suffering from diminished responsibility at the time of the murder, stood trial three years later in November 2021 for the crime. The High Court found her guilty of murder on 18 May 2023,[3][4] and more than a month later, Zin Mar Nwe was sentenced to life in prison on 4 July 2023, after the trial court duly considered that Zin should not be given the death sentence on account that she was a minor when killing the victim and thus, she was spared the gallows and received a life sentence for the brutal crime.[5][6]

Background

Prior to her arrival in Singapore, Zin Mar Nwe, who was born and raised in Myanmar, was hired and trained to become a domestic maid, and she first came to Singapore on 5 January 2018. Even though her real age was 17, the agent responsible for Zin's employment registered her passport and changed her date of birth, claiming that Zin was 23 years old. In fact, the minimum age to work as a maid in Singapore was 23, and being six years younger, Zin would not have been eligible to become a maid by Singapore employment standards. This would be eventually uncovered during police investigations when Zin was arrested for murdering an elderly woman.[7]

After she arrived in Singapore, Zin began working for two Singaporean families (one after the other) between January and May 2018. On 10 May 2018, Zin was hired by an Indian-born financial controller who immigrated and settled in Singapore, and she began working for her employer, who lived at Choa Chu Kang with his wife and two teenage daughters.[8]

Murder

On 26 May 2018, sixteen days after Zin Mar Nwe started working for her third employer, her employer's 70-year-old mother-in-law travelled from India to Singapore to come live with her son-in-law and his kin for a month. During the period of her stay, the elderly Indian citizen allegedly abused the 17-year-old maid Zin Mar Nwe (who never suffered abuse from the other members of the household), hitting her (either with bare hands or other objects) and reprimanding her on several occasions whenever the maid did not perform up to expectations or cannot understand her instructions. On one occasion, while Zin was massaging the elderly woman, she used too much force and the woman slapped her. On another occasion, in the kitchen, Zin had turned on the stove wrongly, and accidentally caused the elderly woman to get her hand burned slightly, causing the woman to pull Zin's hands close to the fire.On a third occasion when Zin was cutting the older woman's toenails, the woman allegedly kicked her in the chest.[9][10]

On the morning of 25 June 2018, Zin Mar Nwe was alone at home with the elderly woman, who threatened to contact her agent and send her back to Myanmar.[11] Zin was emotionally triggered by the threat, especially since she incurred a debt of S$3,300 to come to Singapore to work. In a fit of anger, Zin grabbed a knife from the kitchen and stabbed the woman multiple times while the elderly woman was watching television.[12][13]

The elderly victim, 70-year-old Mehrotra Shashi,[14] died as a result of acute haemorrhage resulting from the 26 stab wounds (some of which penetrated her heart and lungs) on her body. Three of the wounds were sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature.[15] The victim was pronounced dead at about 3.29pm after a neighbour (who heard the screams) discovered her body and the arrival of paramedics.[16][17] Police were also contacted to investigate the case, which was classified as murder, and a manhunt was set out to look for Zin who was their prime suspect. Evidence was also collected from the flat, which was cordoned off for more than twelve hours.[18] Neighbours who interacted with the family were shocked to hear about the gruesome murder and stated that the family (who all lived here for at least 17 years) were generally friendly, and described the maid as a "timid" and small-sized person.[19]

Zin Mar Nwe, who escaped the flat with an EZ-Link card and some cash, wandered around Singapore after the stabbing, and she was arrested five hours later upon her arrival at the maid agency to retrieve her passport.[20][21] Zin was charged with murder two days later on 27 June 2018.[22][23] The case was extensively reported in the Indian media and Singaporean media, and other countries, due to the high-profile nature of the case.[24]

After the completion of the autopsy at the mortuary of the Health Sciences Authority, the victim's son-in-law retrieved the body for funeral preparations, and more than 30 relatives and friends were present at the victim's funeral at Mandai Crematorium.[25]

Trial of Zin Mar Nwe

Prosecution’s case

On 9 November 2021, three years after her arrest, Zin Mar Nwe officially stood trial for murder. A month before the beginning of Zin's trial, in October 2021, the courts issued a gag order to prohibit the local media and newspapers in Singapore from continuing to report the name of the victim, in order to protect the identity of one of the trial witnesses, who was below 18 years old and a family member of the victim. Also, Zin Mar Nwe's age was corrected from 23 to 17 after the authorities got wind of her false declaration in her passport and a bone-age test at Tan Tock Seng Hospital confirmed that Zin was "most likely" 17 years old at the time she murdered the deceased. Even though she was a minor when murdering the victim, Zin was tried as an adult.[26]

The charge of murder against Zin Mar Nwe came under Section 300(c) of the Penal Code, which dictates an offence of murder where an offender intentionally inflicted injuries that were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, which carries either life imprisonment with caning or the death penalty if found guilty.[27]

The prosecution's case was based on Zin's confession. Zin initially claimed that two dark-skinned people entered the flat to attack and stab the victim to death, but subsequently, Zin changed her story and confessed to killing the elderly woman, claiming that as a Buddhist, she should tell the truth.[28] Although Zin gave numerous different accounts about the crime, she nonetheless admitted to killing the victim and also raised the instances where she was abused by the deceased for some time prior to the stabbing,[29] although the family of the deceased testified that Zin looked normal the day before the murder, and stated that they had a cordial relationship with the maid.[30] Zin stated as a result of the threat of being sent back home and fear of incurring debts, she was triggered and lost control when killing the victim.[31]

Defence’s case

Zin's main defence at trial was diminished responsibility. Dr Tommy Tan, the defence's psychiatrist, testified on behalf of Zin during the trial. He was of the opinion that Zin suffered from adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood, which were sufficient to impair her mental responsibility at the time of the crime, and rendered Zin not fully conscious of what she was doing, since she was in a "dissociative state" and could not control or remember her acts when she was stabbing the victim. Christopher Bridges, the lawyer who was assigned by the state to defend Zin, sought to rely on Dr Tan's psychiatric report to reduce his client's charge of murder to culpable homicide not amounting to murder, a lesser offence of unlawful killing that warrant either a sentence of up to twenty years' imprisonment or life in prison.[32]

In response, Dr Alias Lijo, a government psychiatrist from the Institute of Mental Health (IMH), was called by the prosecution to testify on Zin's mental state. Dr Lijo rebutted that Zin did not suffer from diminished responsibility at the time of the murder, stating that she had full knowledge of the magnitude of her actions and never had any abnormality of the mind at the time of the stabbing.[33]

Trial verdict

Conviction

On 18 May 2023, after an 11-day trial that dragged on for more than a year, Justice Andre Maniam, the trial judge presiding over Zin Mar Nwe's case, delivered the verdict.

In his judgement, Justice Maniam stated that he rejected Zin Mar Nwe's defence of diminished responsibility. While he accepted some of Zin's claims that the victim had hit her and scolded her sometimes, Justice Maniam stated that Zin was able to tolerate these instances of mistreatment up until the threat of being sent back home, which triggered her to stab the old woman. The judge found that Zin was not in a dissociative state when she stabbed the victim, and he said Zin was able to intricately describe how she committed the crime and she was aware of what she was doing, and consciously took steps to plan and make her escape in the aftermath of the killing. Justice Maniam also pointed out that Zin had done the stabbing in a fit of anger rather than doing so under an impaired mental state, and described her decision to stab the deceased was an "emotional, irrational" one, which was why he chose to reject Dr Tan's evidence about Zin's alleged mental disorders and accepted Dr Lijo's testimony. Since Zin was conscious of her actions, and had intentionally stabbed the deceased and such that the injuries intentionally inflicted were in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, Justice Maniam found 22-year-old Zin Mar Nwe guilty of murder and convicted her as charged.[34][35][36]

Upon her conviction for murder under Section 300(c) of the Penal Code, Zin Mar Nwe faced a possible death sentence or life imprisonment with caning under Section 302(2) of the Penal Code.[37] However, Zin Mar Nwe cannot be caned as she was a woman.[38]

Sentencing was adjourned to a later date and the prosecution and defence were given four weeks' time to file closing submissions on the sentence. Deputy Public Prosecutor (DPP) Kumaresan Gohulabalan, who led the trial prosecution with his colleague Sean Teh, expressed that they would not seek the death penalty in Zin's case.[39][40] In fact, under the existing laws of Singapore, the death penalty was prohibited in cases where the offender was below 18 years old at the time when they committed murder or other capital crimes. Since Zin was 17 years old when she murdered the elderly woman, she would not be eligible for the death penalty. The only other possible sentence she could receive in this case was life imprisonment.[41][42]

Sentence

On 4 July 2023, 22-year-old Zin Mar Nwe was officially sentenced to life imprisonment by the High Court.[43][44]

The trial judge Andre Maniam noted during sentencing that in accordance to Section 314 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CPC), Zin Mar Nwe cannot be sentenced to death because she was under 18 years old when committing the murder, and thus Justice Maniam could only spare the former maid from the gallows and instead, he meted out a life sentence for Zin Mar Nwe, which was the only sentence permissible by law in her case.[45][46] He also considered the prosecutor Sean Teh's contention that they did not object to a life term in view of the evidence which proved that the defendant was a minor at the time of the offence.[47]

Prior to her sentencing, Zin submitted a letter pleading for a second chance and her lawyers emphasized Zin's homesickness and longing for her boyfriend and parents (who were still in Myanmar). Reportedly, Zin consulted her lawyers about her option to appeal the verdict after the end of her court session.[48][49]

Aftermath

In the aftermath of her sentencing, the case of Zin Mar Nwe also shed light on the phenomenon of underaged maids being employed in Singapore despite the stringent background checks and regulations set to detect underaged maids, and it was found that most of these maids (most of them hailed from Myanmar) were told by their agents to lie about their ages to gain employment in Singapore. The Ministry of Manpower released their data which showed that from 2018 to 2022, the authorities detected around six underage foreign domestic workers per 10,000 such workers in Singapore during that period, in spite of the decline in the number of underage maids detected in the previous three years.[50][51]

Not only that, due to the high-profile nature of Zin’s case, observers who spoke to the national newspaper The Straits Times expressed that based on the situation of the foreign maids in Singapore (268,500 of them as of December 2022), many had faced significant stressors from the multiple responsibilities they need to fulfill, including household duties and meeting expectations of their employers, and it was especially so should it be taking care of the elderly or special needs children, or the maids being either not skilled enough or too young (since younger maids did not have sufficient maturity and lesser self-confidence than the older ones). First-time maids were also noted for having a lack of community bonds in a foreign country and not having friends to seek help or release their stress. Some maids may also found it difficult to adjust to moving from a rural living environment to an urban living environment, and the lack of family support, learning a new language and other factors also add to their emotional struggles, which was the case for Zin Mar Nwe, who had to travel alone from Myanmar to Singapore, where she worked with a salary of S$450 which her family placed total dependence upon.

It was further revealed by the same newspaper that since 2012, there have been 11 reported cases of maids found guilty of killing their employer or the employer's family member, including Zin herself. Seven of these maids were below the age of 25, and four were 18 years old or younger. According to Zin’s lawyer Christopher Bridges, many maids who suffered from mistreatment had to suppress their distress and emotions for fear of being sent back home, and for Zin, the threat of being sent back to Myanmar and incurring debts from her return, compounded by her financial woes and the abuse, had become the proverbial straw that broke the camel’s back, resulting in Zin overwhelmed with anger and thus murdered the 70-year-old victim.[52]

See also

References

  1. ↑ "Pembantu rumah didapati bersalah bunuh ibu mertua majikan". Berita MediaCorp (in Malay). 18 May 2023.
  2. ↑ "Singapore jails Myanmar maid for life over murder of employer's 70-year-old mother-in-law she stabbed 26 times". South China Morning Post. 4 July 2023.
  3. ↑ "26刀捅死男雇主岳母 17岁女佣谋杀罪成立". Johor China Press (in Chinese). 18 May 2023.
  4. ↑ "捅死雇主七旬岳母 17岁缅甸女佣罪成". Sin Chew Daily (in Chinese). 18 May 2023.
  5. ↑ "不堪被打骂26刀捅死雇主七旬岳母 缅甸籍女佣被判终身监禁". 8World News (in Chinese). 4 July 2023.
  6. ↑ "26刀捅死雇主岳母 缅籍女佣终生监禁". Lianhe Zaobao (in Chinese). 4 July 2023.
  7. ↑ "Maid on trial for murdering employer's 70-year-old mother-in-law, leaving 26 stab wounds". CNA. 9 November 2021.
  8. ↑ "Maid found guilty of murdering employer's 70-year-old mother-in-law". Borneo Bulletin. 19 May 2023.
  9. ↑ "Myanmar maid who stabbed employer's mother-in-law 26 times found guilty of murder". The Straits Times. 18 May 2023.
  10. ↑ "Maid on trial for murdering employer's mother-in-law claims she was abused". The Straits Times. 9 November 2021.
  11. ↑ "疑不满遭暴力 女佣连捅26刀致死老妇". Oriental Daily (in Chinese). 9 November 2021.
  12. ↑ "She tolerated abuse, but threat of being sent home triggered maid to stab boss' mum-in-law". The Straits Times. 16 July 2023.
  13. ↑ "Myanmar Helper Stabs S'pore Employer's Mother-In-Law 26 Times, Found Guilty Of Murder". Must Share News. 18 May 2023.
  14. ↑ "70-year-old Indian-origin woman murdered in Singapore allegedly by Myanmarese maid". The Hindustan Times. 27 June 2018.
  15. ↑ "Maid on trial for murder says the victim physically abused her". The Independent. 11 November 2021.
  16. ↑ "蔡厝港发生女佣弑主案". Lianhe Zaobao (in Chinese). 25 June 2018.
  17. ↑ "Myanmar maid was employed just two months before she stabbed 70-year-old female employer to death". The Independent. 28 June 2018.
  18. ↑ "邻居听见女人尖叫声，女佣弒阿嫲". Johor China Press (in Chinese). 26 June 2018.
  19. ↑ "工作不到两个月 女佣多刀捅死70岁老妇". Oriental Daily (in Chinese). 26 June 2018.
  20. ↑ "工作不到两个月 女佣涉多刀夺命 老妇胸颈遭刺穿". Lianhe Zaobao (in Chinese). 25 June 2018.
  21. ↑ "Maid, 24, arrested for suspected murder of 70-year-old woman in Choa Chu Kang". The Straits Times. 25 June 2018.
  22. ↑ "Myanmar maid charged with murder of 70-year-old woman in HDB flat". The Straits Times. 27 June 2018.
  23. ↑ "Maid charged with murder". The Star. 28 June 2018.
  24. ↑ "Indian-origin woman murdered by Myanmar maid in Singapore". Times of India. 27 June 2018.
  25. ↑ "Myanmar maid charged with murder of 70-year-old woman". The New Paper. 28 June 2018.
  26. ↑ "I was abused by victim: Maid accused of stabbing employer's mother-in-law to death". Yahoo News. 8 November 2021.
  27. ↑ "Maid in Singapore on trial for murdering employer's elderly mother-in-law who allegedly abused her". Malay Mail. 9 November 2021.
  28. ↑ "Maid, 22, who stabbed employer's mother-in-law 26 times in 2018 found guilty of murder". Mothership. 18 May 2023.
  29. ↑ "Maid on trial for murdering employer's elderly mother-in-law who allegedly abused her". TODAY. 9 November 2021.
  30. ↑ "Maid on trial for murdering employer's mother-in-law was 'normal' the day before". The Straits Times. 6 January 2022.
  31. ↑ "Myanmar maid who stabbed employer's mother-in-law 26 times found guilty of murder". The New Paper. 18 May 2023.
  32. ↑ "Myanmar domestic helper found guilty of murdering Singapore employer's elderly mother-in-law". South China Morning Post. 18 May 2023.
  33. ↑ "Public Prosecutor v Zin Mar Nwe" (PDF). Singapore Law Watch. 18 May 2023.
  34. ↑ "Maid found guilty of murdering employer's 70-year-old mother-in-law". CNA. 18 May 2023.
  35. ↑ "17岁缅甸女佣捅死雇主七旬岳母被判罪成". 8World News (in Chinese). 18 May 2023.
  36. ↑ "26刀捅死男雇主岳母 女佣谋杀罪成立". Lianhe Zaobao (in Chinese). 18 May 2023.
  37. ↑ "Public Prosecutor v Zin Mar Nwe". Supreme Court judgements. 18 May 2023.
  38. ↑ "Caning in Singapore: Judicial, School & Parental Corporal Punishment". Singapore Legal Advice. 22 April 2019.
  39. ↑ "Maid found guilty of murdering employer's 70-year-old mother-in-law". TODAY. 18 May 2023.
  40. ↑ "Maid found guilty of murdering employer's mother-in-law". AsiaOne. 18 May 2023.
  41. ↑ "How Long Is Life Imprisonment in Singapore? And Other FAQs". Singapore Legal Advice. 1 February 2021.
  42. ↑ "Teen maid in Singapore escapes gallows, gets life imprisonment for stabbing employer's mother-in-law to death". Malay Mail. 4 July 2023.
  43. ↑ "Myanmar maid who stabbed employer's mum-in-law 26 times gets life term for murder". The Straits Times. 4 July 2023.
  44. ↑ "Myanmar maid who stabbed employer's mum-in-law 26 times gets life term for murder". The New Paper. 4 July 2023.
  45. ↑ "26刀捅死雇主岳母 缅籍女佣终生监禁". Sin Chew Daily (in Chinese). 4 July 2023.
  46. ↑ "Domestic worker, 22, gets life imprisonment for stabbing S'pore employer's mom-in-law 26 times". Mothership. 4 July 2023.
  47. ↑ "Teen maid escapes gallows, gets life imprisonment for stabbing employer's mother-in-law to death". TODAY. 4 July 2023.
  48. ↑ "Maid sentenced to life imprisonment for murdering 70-year-old woman by stabbing her 26 times". CNA. 4 July 2023.
  49. ↑ "Amah dihukum penjara seumur hidup; tikam wanita 70 tahun 26 kali sampai mati". Berita MediaCorp (in Malay). 4 July 2023.
  50. ↑ "Maid agencies find various ways to sieve out underage candidates, even as MOM sees fewer cases". TODAY. 12 July 2023.
  51. ↑ "IN FOCUS: Why do underage maids risk working illegally in Singapore, and how do they slip through the cracks?". CNA. 29 July 2023.
  52. ↑ "Maids face significant stress from juggling multiple responsibilities: Observers". The Straits Times. 16 July 2023.
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.