"Too much racing"

The 1910 racing season at Indianapolis Motor Speedway began well, with an estimated 60,000 spectators for the 200 mi (320 km) Wheeler-Schebler Trophy on Memorial Day, won by Ray Harroun.^[3] Throughout the remainder of the season, however, the crowds grew progressively smaller, and after seeing a second decline in attendance in as many days for Labor Day, September 5, 1910, the final day of the concluding meet, Speedway co-founders Carl Fisher, James Allison, Arthur Newby and Frank Wheeler conferred to decide on a new course for the following year.

While the appearance on Monday of some 18,000 was reasonable enough, given both the rain showers occurring early that morning and the large parade held downtown during the afternoon, neither the two days of the Labor Day meet nor the July 4 weekend races had come near to equaling the Memorial Day turnout. While potential explanations for the decline included the high heat of summer and the women of the city making family holiday plans that did not include automobile racing, one of the most likely, they reasoned, was an overabundance of the very events they exhibited: too many races had diluted turnout down to only those most interested in the sport.^[4]

Timing

By the next day, Tuesday, September 6, 1910, local newspapers had already heard rumors of the decision, and reported that the four partners would likely soon choose to concentrate on a singular, major event for 1911. Most strongly considered were either a 24-hour contest — anticipating the 24 Hours of Le Mans, itself inaugurated just a dozen years later — or a 1,000 mi (1,600 km) endurance race, with a spectacular purse of $25,000;^[5] equivalent to 37.615 kg (82.93 lb) of pure gold, and more than high enough to attract global as well as national and regional competition.^[3] The endurance event was favored by several manufacturers, but debate soon proceeded as to what would be most beneficial to the spectators as well as the participants. While a 24-hour race would be possible on a technical level despite its extreme nature, all agreed that potential ticket-buyers would inevitably depart the grounds well before its conclusion. Deciding on a "race window" extending from 10:00AM to late afternoon, local time, early estimates placed the planned race distance at 300 to 500 miles (480 to 800 km). The race winner, with purse estimates ranging toward $30,000, could expect to see as much as $12,000.^[4]

In choices for a specific date to hold the race, Memorial Day, already the occasion of the largest attendance, was always foremost. As suggested to the Speedway owners by business associate Lem Trotter, the time coincided with the completion of a late-spring agricultural practice known as "haying," after which the farmers acquired an effective two-week break. While the intention, Trotter argued, would certainly be to draw from far more than just the local farming community, simple business sense called for as little interference as possible with the regional economy. That such an opportunity to avoid a conflict of interest fell on a major national holiday sealed the decision: within two days, formal announcement was made of a 500-mile (800 km), marathon-distance motor race, to be held at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, May 30, 1911.^[4]

Preparation, and the "Month of May"

As desired and expected, news of a contest of such distance evoked strong enthusiasm both within and without the motorsport community. Newspaper and trade magazine articles used ever-new superlatives for the challenges expected to soon face both drivers and engineers, and continuing discussion throughout the spring and winter kept the race as the primary conversation piece of the average citizen. Everyone, it seemed, had something to say about it.^[6]

Due to the publicity thus created, Speedway management, which had for the previous two seasons of meets charged the effectively nominal entry fee of one dollar per mile of scheduled race distances, took measures to ensure that the likely large entry list did not include any that were frivolous: at an accordingly heightened fee of $500 per car, participation became a nominally risky proposition to teams and manufacturers, since, although the high finishers were due to receive record purse money and accessory prizes, no money at all was offered to finishers below tenth place. Interest, however, was far from dampened, with entry blanks distributed over the course of the following month quickly returning filled, the first of which being an automobile built by the J. I. Case Threshing Machine Company of Racine, Wisconsin, to be driven by Lewis Strang. By May 1, 1911, the final day for entry filing, a high total of some 46 cars had been nominated to compete.^[6]

May 1 also marked the beginning of a long tradition of the opening of the Speedway, on the first day of the month of the race, to free practice on the circuit during daylight hours by any and all participants. A policy originally established so as to allow teams unfamiliar with the 2.5-mile (4.0 km), recently brick-paved high-speed course as much time to acclimate as necessary, the "Month of May", as it came to be called in future years, ultimately proved most advantageous in the short-term to the locally based teams, given that many of the entries from abroad did not even set out for the city until well into the month. One such example, the double-entry Pope-Hartford team based in Springfield, Massachusetts, came by way of the team's actual racing cars themselves simply being driven cross-country, while loaded up with toolboxes and as many spare parts as they could hold, making overnight stops in New York City, Buffalo, Cleveland and Columbus, Ohio, before finally arriving, where they were duly met at the city's East Washington Street by Frank Fox, who was not only the slated driver of one of the two cars but also the company's local agent.

Ultimately, of the full forty-six entries originally submitted, only the two cars of the Falcar team from Moline, Illinois failed to appear, due to an inability to acquire critical chassis pieces.^[6]

Setting the field

Starting grid on race morning.

To further refine the entry list as the date of the race approached, a qualification system was implemented whereby each car would be required to demonstrate a sufficiently competitive pace. With several of the top entries having already recorded, during the "unofficial" practice time of the month, complete laps at up to 88 mph (142 km/h), a minimum required speed of 75 mph (121 km/h), based on a flying start over a 0.25 miles (0.40 km) section of the main straightaway, was considered to be within reason. Thus, all cars successfully completing an officially-timed run of the quarter-mile distance at or under 12 seconds would be accepted into the starting field; those that did not would be given two additional attempts before being rejected, a policy that began the tradition of three qualification attempts allotted to each entered car.

In the years following these inaugural qualification sessions, which were held on May 27 and 28, 1911, anecdotes would occasionally arise, and thereafter be steadily embellished in their retelling, regarding the purported qualifying times and speeds of given competitors, and how they compared to one another. In reality, no records of the sessions were kept at all, let alone publicized, with the sole objective being the confirmation of each car's capability to achieve the minimum speed. Also in contrast to later eras, both the starting order and the car numbering of the participants were determined not by respective speeds or previous seasonal point totals, but by entry date, with the Strang-driven Case entry being assigned #1 in the first starting position.^[6]

Controversy

Upon Harroun's declared victory, second-place finisher Mulford supposedly protested, contending he had lapped Harroun when the Marmon limped in on the torn tire, an argument appearing plausible to some, due to an accident disrupting the official timing and scoring stand at nearly the same time. However, race officials were quick to note Mulford's subsequent pit stop forced the Lozier crew to spend several minutes themselves changing a tire which stuck to the wheel hub; Mulford's protest was thus denied.^[12]

According to track historian Donald Davidson, no protests were filed at the end of the race^[13] and Mulford offered congratulations to Harroun in the Detroit Free Press newspaper on June 4.^[14][13][15] Davidson has also pointed out that Mulford was reported by contemporary publications to have changed 14 tires during the course of the race,^[13] including one from a blown tire in turn one.^[16] Changing tires at the time was a lengthy and painstaking process, as the wheels were typically not removable. Tires had to be pried off of the rims, remounted, and inflated - all using hand tools, and in the precarious confines of the primitive pit stalls. Mulford himself even understood and admitted that he lost at least 14 minutes of track position due to his numerous pit stops.^[14]

After blowing the tire on turn one, Mulford had to limp around the track for almost an entire lap, and subsequently bent the rim.^[13] That necessitated an even longer pit stop at that juncture to hammer out the damage. The accounts from the newspapers claim that Harroun changed only four tires all day during only three pit stops. Harroun's team changed the right rear tire three times, and one other unspecified tire.^[16][13] Harroun's shorter elapsed time in the pits is alone considered sufficient to more than overcome any track position advantage Mulford might have been thought to have. But the undermining evidence to support Harroun as the rightful winner was the team strategy to run a constant 75 mph pace, regardless of position, in order to save tire wear.^[17] During the 1910 Wheeler-Schebler Trophy Race, as well as during test runs in May 1911, Harroun discovered that by merely running a constant 75 mph pace instead of an 80 mph (or faster) pace, he would substantially reduce his tire wear and increase tire life.^[13][18]

Davidson contends that Mulford did not make serious claims to victory later in life, as some have suggested.^[15] And in fact the controversy itself did not begin to inflame until decades after the race.^[13] Likewise, internet-based urban legends, and a book published in 2011, have fueled the controversy. It is also possible that Mulford's statements in the Detroit Free Press interview^[14] were misunderstood or purposely misconstrued. While giving full credit to Harroun for winning the race, Mulford did for himself claim the world record for 500 miles driven solo (Harroun had relief help from Cyrus Patschke). He also made the largely inconsequential claim that minus the stoppage time needed for pit stops (over 14 minutes), he likely completed the 500 miles (running time only) in less elapsed time than Harroun & Patschke.^[14]

Starting grid

1911 Indianapolis 500-Mile Race Qualification Results
Starting grid determined by order of entry date. No qualification times or speeds recorded, only success or failure to qualify.[6]
Entries required to maintain an excess of 75 mph (121 km/h) over a quarter-mile distance to qualify.[6]
Row	No	Far Inside	No	Inside Center	No	Center	No	Outside Center	No	Far Outside
1	Pace Car Position		1	Lewis Strang  R	2	Ralph DePalma  R	3	Harry Endicott  R	4	Johnny Aitken  R
2	5	Louis Disbrow  R	6	Frank Fox  R	7	Harry Knight  R	8	Joe Jagersberger  R	9	Will Jones  R
3	10	Gil Andersen  R	11	Spencer Wishart  R	12	W. H. Turner  R	15	Fred Belcher  R	16	Arthur Chevrolet  R
4	17	Charles Basle  R	18	Eddie Hearne  R	19	Harry Grant  R	20	Charlie Merz  R	21	Howdy Wilcox  R
5	23	Mel Marquette*  R	24	Fred Ellis  R	25	Harry Cobe  R	26	Jack Tower  R	27	Ernest Delany  R
6	28	David Bruce-Brown  R	30	Lee Frayer  R	31	Joe Dawson  R	32	Ray Harroun  R	33	Ralph Mulford  R
7	34	Teddy Tetzlaff  R	35	Herbert Lytle  R	36	Hughie Hughes  R	37	Charles Bigelow  R	38	Ralph Beardsley  R
8	39	Caleb Bragg  R	41	Howard Hall  R	42	Bill Endicott  R	44	Arthur Greiner  R	45	Bob Burman  R
9	46	Billy Knipper  R
DNQ	Louis Edmunds  R		Rupert Jeffkins  R

* Entry started in race by Bert Adams, finished by Mel Marquette.

Race results

1911 Indianapolis 500-Mile Race
Race finishing times recorded down to second intervals.
All entries still running at conclusion scored ahead of non-finishing entries, regardless of race completion percentage.
Pos	No	Driver	Entrant	Chassis (car name)	Engine			Start Pos	Laps Led*	Laps Run	Time (interval)	Speed (mph) (km/h)	Status	Prize Money ($)
					Cyl	Displ
						(in3)	(L)
1	32	Ray Harroun**  R  (relieved by Cyrus Patschke ( R )	Nordyke & Marmon Company	Marmon Wasp	Marmon			28	88	200	6:42:08	74.602 120.060	finished	14,250
					6	477	7.82
2	33	Ralph Mulford  R	Lozier Motor Company	Lozier	Lozier			29	10	200	6:43:51 +0:01:43	74.285 119.550	finished	5,200
					4	544	8.91
3	28	David Bruce-Brown  R	E. E. Hewlett	Fiat	Fiat			25	81	200	6:52:29 +0:10:21	72.730 117.048	finished	3,250
					4	589	9.65
4	11	Spencer Wishart  R  (relieved by Dave Murphy  R )	Spencer Wishart	Mercedes	Mercedes			11	5	200	6:52:57 +0:10:49	72.648 116.916	finished	2,350
					4	583	9.55
5	31	Joe Dawson  R  (relieved by Cyrus Patschke  R )	Nordyke & Marmon Company	Marmon	Marmon			27	0	200	6:54:34 +0:12:26	72.365 116.460	finished	1,500
					4	495	8.11
6	2	Ralph DePalma  R	Simplex Automobile Company	Simplex	Simplex			2	4	200	7:02:02 +0:19:54	71.084 114.399	finished	1,000
					4	597	9.78
7	20	Charlie Merz  R  (relieved by Len Zengel  R )	National Motor Vehicle Company	National	National			18	0	200	7:06:20 +0:24:12	70.367 113.245	finished	800
					4	447	7.33
8	12	W. H. Turner  R  (relieved by Walter Jones  R )	Simplex Automobile Company	Amplex	Amplex			12	0	200	7:15:56 +0:33:48	68.818 110.752	finished	700
					4	443	7.26
9	15	Fred Belcher  R  (relieved by John Coffey  R )	Knox Automobile Company	Knox	Knox			13	4	200	7:17:09 +0:35:01	68.626 110.443	finished	600
					6	432	7.08
10	25	Harry Cobe  R  (relieved by Louis Schwitzer  R )	Jackson Automobile Company	Jackson	Jackson			22	0	200	7:21:50 +0:39:42	67.899 109.273	finished	500
					4	559	9.16
11	10	Gil Andersen  R	Ideal Motor Car Company	Stutz	Wisconsin			10	0	200	7:22:55 +0:40:47	67.73 109.001	finished	0
					4	390	6.39
12	36	Hughie Hughes  R	Mercer Motors Company	Mercer	Mercer			32	0	200	7:23:32 +0:41:24	67.63 108.840	finished	0
					4	300	4.92
13	30	Lee Frayer  R  (relieved by Eddie Rickenbacker  R )	Columbus Buggy Company	Firestone-Columbus	Firestone-Columbus			26	0	197	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	432	7.08
14	21	Howdy Wilcox  R	National Motor Vehicle Company	National	National			19	0	194	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	589	9.65
15	37	Charles Bigelow  R  (relieved by W. H. Frey  R ) (relieved by E. H. Sherwood  R )	Mercer Motors Company	Mercer	Mercer			33	0	194	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	300	4.92
16	3	Harry Endicott  R	Inter-State Automobile Company	Inter-State	Inter-State			3	0	192	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	390	6.39
17	41	Howard Hall  R  (relieved by Rupert Jeffkins  R )	Velie Motors Corporation	Velie	Velie			36	0	190	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	334	5.47
18	46	Billy Knipper  R	E. A. Moross	Benz	Benz			40	0	188	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	444	7.28
19	45	Bob Burman  R	E. A. Moross	Benz	Benz			39	0	183	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	520	8.52
20	38	Ralph Beardsley  R  (relieved by Frank Goode  R )	Simplex Automobile Company	Simplex	Simplex			34	0	178	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	597	9.78
21	18	Eddie Hearne  R  (relieved by Edward Parker  R )	Edward A. Hearne	Fiat	Fiat			16	0	175	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	487	7.98
22	6	Frank Fox  R  (relieved by Fred Clemons  R )	Pope Manufacturing Company	Pope-Hartford	Pope-Hartford			6	0	162	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	390	6.39
23	27	Ernest Delany  R	Clark-Carter Automobile Company	Cutting	Cutting			24	0	160	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	390	6.39
24	26	Jack Tower  R  (relieved by Robert Evans  R )	Jackson Automobile Company	Jackson	Jackson			23	0	145	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	432	7.08
25	23	Bert Adams  R  (started) Mel Marquette  R  (finished)	Speed Motors Company	McFarlan	McFarlan			20	0	142	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					6	377	6.18
26	42	Bill Endicott  R  (relieved by John Jenkins  R )	Cole Motor Car Company	Cole	Cole			37	0	104	flagged		flagged, still running	0
					4	471	7.72
27	4	Johnny Aitken  R	National Motor Vehicle Company	National	National			4	8	125	did not finish		connecting rod	0
					4	589	9.65
28	9	Will Jones  R	Case Corporation	Case	Wisconsin			9	0	122	did not finish		steering	0
					4	284	4.65
29	1	Lewis Strang  R  (relieved by Elmer Ray  R )	Case Corporation	Case	Wisconsin			1	0	109	did not finish		steering	0
					4	284	4.65
30	7	Harry Knight  R	Westcott Motor Car Company	Westcott	Westcott			7	0	90	did not finish		accident, front-straight	0
					6	421	6.90
31	8	Joe Jagersberger  R	Case Corporation	Case	Wisconsin			8	0	87	did not finish		accident, front-straight	0
					4	284	4.65
32	35	Herbert Lytle  R	Apperson Brothers Automotive Company	Apperson	Apperson			31	0	82	did not finish		accident, pits	0
					4	546	8.95
33	19	Harry Grant  R	American Locomotive Company	Alco	Alco			17	0	51	did not finish		bearings	0
					6	580	9.50
34	17	Charles Basle  R	Buick Motor Company	Buick	Buick			15	0	46	did not finish		mechanical	0
					4	594	9.73
35	5	Louis Disbrow  R	Pope Manufacturing Company	Pope-Hartford	Pope-Hartford			5	0	45	did not finish		accident, front-straight	0
					4	390	6.39
36	16	Arthur Chevrolet  R	Buick Motor Company	Buick	Buick			14	0	30	did not finish		mechanical	0
					4	594	9.73
37	39	Caleb Bragg  R	Caleb S. Bragg	Fiat	Fiat			35	0	24	did not finish		wrecked, pits	0
					4	487	7.98
38	24	Fred Ellis  R	Jackson Automobile Company	Jackson	Jackson			21	0	22	did not finish		fire damage, withdrawn	0
					4	355	5.82
39	34	Teddy Tetzlaff  R	Lozier Motor Company	Lozier	Lozier			30	0	20	did not finish		accident, front-straight	0
					4	544	8.91
40	44	Arthur Greiner  R	Simplex Automobile Company	Amplex	Amplex			38	0	12	did not finish		accident, second turn	0
					4	443	7.26
Sources:[19][20][21]

Notes

* Due to an accident at the timing and scoring stand, laps 138 through 176 were unofficially recorded.

** Ray Harroun was relieved by Cyrus Patschke for approximately 35 laps at the halfway point of the race.

References

Works cited

• Jaslow, Russel (1997). "Who Really Won the First Indy 500?". Retrieved June 16, 2006.
• 2006 Indianapolis 500 Official Program
• Summary of race at www.champcarstars.com