2016: two-year-old season

Abel Tasman made her first start on August 20, 2016, at Del Mar Racetrack, finishing fifth. She won her next start on September 30 at Santa Anita Park in a maiden special weight race, then won again in an allowance rate on November 18 at Del Mar.^[1]

For her final start of the year, Abel Tasman was entered for a supplementary fee of $10,000 in the Grade I Starlet Stakes at Santa Anita over a distance of 1+1⁄16 miles. She went off at odds of 13–1, while the odds-on favorite was the highly regarded American Gal. Abel Tasman got off to a slow start then started her move around the far turn while racing five wide. Nearing the finish line, she caught American Gal to win by a length.^[9] "I think the distance is the key for this filly", said Callaghan. "We decided to supplement because she was getting good at the right time and I thought she had the stamina for this race."^[10]

2017: three-year-old season

Abel Tasman started her three-year-old campaign on March 4, 2017, in the Santa Ysabel Stakes at Santa Anita. Heavy favorite Unique Bella, considered one of the top fillies in training, went to the early lead and set comfortable fractions. Abel Tasman made a run down the stretch and closed to within a length before Unique Bella responded to her jockey's urging and drew away late to win by 2+1⁄2 lengths. "Turning for home, I had a lot of horse under me", said jockey Joe Talamo. "Hat's off to the winner. What a special filly she is, because... I really had a lot of horse and we had a beautiful trip."^[11]

Shortly after the race, it was announced that Abel Tasman would be moved from Callaghan's care to the barn of Bob Baffert. During the Santa Ysabel, Talamo had worn the silks of Clearsky Farms although he was supposed to have worn the colors of China Horse Club. According to Callaghan, China Horse Club did not accept his apology for the mix-up.^[7]

Her next start was the Santa Anita Oaks on April 8. Because of an injury to Unique Bella that kept her out of the race, Abel Tasman became the heavy favorite under new jockey Mike Smith. However, she again finished second after the lightly raced Paradise Woods got off to a large early lead and won by a record 11+3⁄4 lengths. "You know, (Paradise Woods) really just blew the field away", said Smith. "I made sure we got second. There was no catching the winner. And that was good enough for today. We’re going to have to go back to the drawing board, make a couple of changes, tweak this and tweak that a little, and see if we can turn the page in the Kentucky Oaks."^[12]

One of the changes that Baffert decided to make was adding blinkers. "They're little ones and they just keep her focused. She'll be competitive now, but it's a tough deal. There are some really good fillies in there. She needs to get away and not be so far back."^[13]

Abel Tasman was the fourth betting choice in the Kentucky Oaks, held on May 5 at Churchill Downs over a sloppy (sealed) track. Paradise Woods went to the early lead with Miss Sky Warrior, followed by Farrell in third place. The front runners, who were also the top betting choices, set rapid opening fractions, especially considering the track conditions. All three eventually tired and finished well back. Meanwhile, Abel Tasman broke poorly and was last in the field of fourteen as they headed into the first turn, though she had good position near the rail. In the final turn, Smith moved the filly six wide to get around traffic. She responded with a strong run to win by 1+1⁄4 lengths.^[14] "For as far back as I was, I knew they were going quick", said Smith. "Once I got her out in the middle of the track... I knew she was going to run well at that point."^[15]

After the race, part owner Teo Ah Khing said, "We hope that today's race, which is very significant, will put the geographical location and the significance of Kentucky Oaks in the mind of the Chinese, to understand the significance of this race.^[6] Asked about the change of trainers in March, the racing manager of China Horse Club stated, "We won't comment on it. Simon's a very good trainer and he trained her to a (Grade I) win. Bob's also a champion trainer and he's carried that on. We're thankful for both and everybody can just move on from this moment."^[16]

Abel Tasman made her next start at Belmont Park on June 10 in the Acorn Stakes, a one-turn mile. The 2-1 favorite, she raced in last place down the backstretch, then started to make up ground on the turn. Smith found an opening on the rail as they rounded into the stretch and Abel Tasman quickly took charge, then held off the challenge of Salty on the outside.^[17]

On July 23, Abel Tasman was entered in the Coaching Club American Oaks at Saratoga, run at a distance of 1+1⁄8 miles. She broke poorly and settled near the back of the field of seven, but was urged to the lead down the backstretch when the pace slowed. As they turned into the stretch, Salty mounted a brief challenge on the outside while Elate started closing ground on the rail. Smith guided Abel Tasman closer towards the rail, making it harder for Elate to go by. The two dueled for the final furlong with Abel Tasman prevailing by a head. The stewards mounted an inquiry about possible interference in the stretch run but allowed the results to stand. "It's just good, old-fashioned race riding", said Smith. "By no means did I put (Elate) in any harm. My filly really waits (for other horses to challenge her). Once she was in there, she was engaged. I made sure that I didn't touch (Elate). I made it tight, but there's no rules that say you can't make it tight."^[18]

Abel Tasman was then shipped to Parx Racing in Pennsylvania for the $1 million Cotillion Stakes on September 23. She broke slowly but then rushed up into second down the backstretch. She continued to duel with Lockdown for the lead as they entered the stretch, but meanwhile It Tiz Well mounted a strong move in the middle of the track and pulled ahead. Abel Tasman responded to the new challenge too late and finished second by two lengths. "She got real rank with (Smith), she took off with him it, and it was unfortunate", said Baffert. "It was a ridiculous run. We might have to take the blinkers off. I guess we just have to turn the page."^[19]

On November 3, Abel Tasman made her final start of the year in the Breeders' Cup Distaff, where she faced older horses for the first time. The favorite was Elate, who had won the Alabama and Beldame Stakes after finishing second to Abel Tasman in the Coaching Club American Oaks. The older horse division was led by champion Stellar Wind (Apple Blossom, Beholder Mile, Clement L. Hirsch) and Forever Unbridled (Fleur de Lis, Personal Ensign).^[20] Abel Tasman trailed the field for the first half mile, then swung wide around the final turn and started to close ground rapidly. However, Forever Unbridled had made an earlier move to hit the lead and was able to hold off Abel Tasman by half a length. "She ran her race", said Baffert. "She just got beat by a really good horse."^[21]

Abel Tasman was voted American Champion Three-Year-Old Filly for 2017.^[22]

2018: four-year-old season

After the Breeders' Cup, Abel Tasman was turned out for a few weeks of rest. Baffert did not rush her return as he planned to focus her campaign on the second half of the season and another chance at the Breeders' Cup Distaff. She made her four-year-old debut in the La Troienne Stakes at Churchill Downs on May 4, 2018, a year after her biggest win in the Kentucky Oaks. She was the only Grade I winner in the race^[8] and went off as the odds-on favorite. However, she raced wide throughout the race and lacked her normal closing kick, finishing fourth behind Salty.^[23]

Abel Tasman made her next start in the Ogden Phipps Stakes on June 5 at Belmont Park, the same day Baffert would win the American Triple Crown with Justify.^[24] She stalked the early pace then moved to the lead on the backstretch when the pace slowed down. She maintained an easy lead around the turn then opened up down the stretch, eventually winning by 7+1⁄4 lengths. "I'm so proud of her", said Baffert. "She's one of my favorite all-time horses."^[25]

Abel Tasman at the 2018 Breeders' Cup

On August 25, Abel Tasman started in the Personal Ensign Stakes at Saratoga as the 3-5 favorite. Her main rival was Elate, the filly she had defeated the year before in the Coaching Club American Oaks after surviving a stewards' inquiry. After half a mile, Abel Tasman moved to the lead on a rail-hugging trip. Elate was racing behind her, then swung wide as they rounded the final turn. Elate started to close ground rapidly, getting to within half a length in mid stretch. Elate then started to drift out, then was guided back to her original path. Meanwhile, Abel Tasman moved away from the rail and the two fillies bumped. Elate lost her momentum and lost by a neck. Elate's jockey filed an objection but the steward's let the result stand.^[26]

The result proved controversial, with the crowd booing Abel Tasman and Smith in the winner's circle. Elate's jockey José Ortiz stated, "He (Smith) clearly came out, knocked my filly off balance, knocked me off balance and beat me by a neck. I think [Abel Tasman] should have come down, 100 percent." Smith disagreed, saying, "We just kind of came together, I didn't herd him [Ortiz] at all and she wasn't going to let him by no matter what."^[26]

Abel Tasman made her next start as the heavy favorite in the Zenyatta Stakes on September 30. She broke poorly and trailed the field early by ten lengths. Turning for home, she lacked her usual closing kick, finishing fifth. "I'm just really not sure what happened with her today", said Smith. "I'm kind of at a loss for words. The good thing is that she didn't get outrun. She didn't run period. For whatever reason she was lethargic loading and she was slow into stride and never wanted to pick it up."^[27]

On November 3, Abel Tasman was entered in the Breeders Cup Distaff, held in 2018 at Churchill Downs. Smith rode her aggressively from the gate and secured third place to the inside of Monomoy Girl going around the turn. She held her position down the backstretch but did not respond when Monomoy Girl started her drive, eventually finishing last. "She just quit running", said Baffert. "I thought she was in a good spot, (Smith) got aggressive with her, but she just doesn't want to run anymore, it looks like."^[28]